From 100+ UX Issues to 68% User Satisfaction Increase

The Challenge

A well-established enterprise software company in a highly regulated industry approached Guac with concerning user adoption metrics and escalating support costs. Their core platform facilitated critical business relationships and document workflows that required absolute precision and security compliance.

The problem symptoms were clear:

• User adoption challenges despite significant development investment
• Increasing support ticket volume related to user experience confusion
• Complex workflows causing user abandonment at critical conversion points
• Accessibility compliance concerns in regulated industry environment
• Inconsistent user experience across the platform's extensive feature set

The strategic implications were serious: Product-market fit questions were arising from user experience friction, creating competitive disadvantage and compliance risk. Without clear improvement priorities, the company faced resource allocation uncertainty and stakeholder alignment challenges.

Previous attempts to address user experience issues had been reactive and piecemeal. Leadership recognized they needed comprehensive strategic design expertise to evaluate their entire product experience, identify systematic issues, and create an actionable roadmap for improvement.

Our Strategic Audit Methodology

Guac's comprehensive audit methodology goes beyond surface-level evaluation to uncover systematic user experience and business logic issues that impact both user satisfaction and business outcomes.

Phase 1: Comprehensive Product Evaluation

• Heuristic Analysis: Systematic evaluation against established UX principles and industry best practices
• Accessibility Compliance Review: WCAG 2.1 AA standard assessment for inclusive design
• User Flow Mapping: Critical path analysis across primary user journeys and workflows
• Information Architecture Assessment: Content organization, navigation logic, and mental model alignment
• Business Logic Evaluation: Feature alignment with business objectives and user goals

Phase 2: Issue Classification and Strategic Prioritization

• Severity Categorization: Critical, major, minor, and accessibility violation classifications
• Business Impact Scoring: Revenue, retention, and acquisition impact evaluation
• Implementation Complexity Assessment: Development effort and resource requirements
• Quick Wins Identification: High-impact, low-effort improvement opportunities

The Guac Differentiator: Implementation Partnership

Unlike traditional audit companies that deliver reports and disappear, Guac's strategic design partnership includes systematic implementation of prioritized improvements. We don't just identify problems—we solve them.

‍
‍What We Discovered

Quantified Results

• 100+ distinct usability, accessibility, and logic issues identified across platform
• 15+ critical user flow disruptions preventing task completion
• 25+ accessibility violations creating barriers for users with disabilities
• 30+ logic inconsistencies causing user confusion and workflow interruption
• 20+ mobile experience gaps significantly degrading cross-device usability

Issue Category Breakdown

- Navigation and Information Architecture (35% of issues) Complex navigation structures preventing efficient feature discovery and mental model misalignment between user expectations and product structure.
- Workflow and Process Design (25% of issues) Multi-step process interruptions causing user abandonment and unclear progress indicators creating uncertainty in complex workflows.
- Accessibility and Compliance (20% of issues) Keyboard navigation barriers and color contrast violations affecting visual accessibility and screen reader compatibility.
- Consistency and Design System (20% of issues)Inconsistent interaction patterns for similar functions across platform and visual hierarchy confusion affecting content prioritization.

Strategic Insights Uncovered

• User onboarding complexity preventing successful platform adoption
• Feature discoverability issues hiding valuable functionality from users
• Cognitive load problems overwhelming users with unnecessary complexity
• Trust and security perception gaps affecting user confidence in sensitive workflows

Solution Approach: Strategic Implementation

We developed a comprehensive prioritization matrix that balanced business impact, user experience improvement, and implementation feasibility to create an actionable improvement roadmap.

Priority Level 1: Critical Business Blockers

• User flow completion barriers preventing core business transactions
• Accessibility compliance violations creating legal and inclusion risks
• Security perception issues affecting user trust in sensitive workflows
• Mobile experience gaps limiting platform accessibility

Priority Level 2: Major User Experience Improvements

• Navigation simplification for improved feature discoverability
• Workflow streamlining to reduce user cognitive load
• Error handling enhancement for better user guidance and recovery
• Information architecture optimization for intuitive content organization

Priority Level 3: Consistency and Polish Optimizations

• Design system establishment for scalable consistency
• Visual hierarchy improvements for better content scanning
• Interaction pattern standardization across platform features

Implementation Strategy: Beyond Traditional Audit

Phase 1: Immediate Impact Solutions
‍Critical workflow fixes addressing highest-impact user blockers and quick accessibility wins improving compliance and inclusion.
‍
Phase 2: Strategic UX Improvements
‍Information architecture restructuring for intuitive navigation and user onboarding redesign to improve activation rates.
‍
Phase 3: Design System and Scalability
‍Comprehensive design system development for consistent future development and advanced accessibility compliance.

Results and Impact

Immediate Strategic Value Delivered

• Clear product improvement roadmap with prioritized, actionable recommendations
• Systematic issue documentation enabling efficient development resource allocation
• Stakeholder alignment achievement on user experience priorities and business impact
• Risk mitigation completion through accessibility compliance gap identification

Implementation Partnership Outcomes

Unlike traditional audit engagements that end with report delivery, Guac's strategic design partnership continues with systematic implementation of prioritized improvements.

Ongoing Strategic Partnership Value

• Design system development for scalable, consistent future improvements
• Continuous optimization through iterative design and user feedback cycles
• Development team collaboration building internal user experience capability
• Business metric improvement tracking design impact on key performance indicators